Oleksandr Kuzmenko, EditorPublished 3 min readAI-assisted · editor-reviewed
TL;DR
- Gemini 4 Carbon took close to an hour on tasks Opus and Astra completed in minutes.
- Testers described Gemini 4 Carbon as unacceptably slow in real-world usage.
- Subscription subsidization for Carbon is 3x, compared to 13x for Astra, 17x for Hydrogen, and 40x for Opus at post-introductory pricing.
Key facts
- Observed Task Latency
- Close to 1 hour (vs. minutes for Opus and Astra)
- Carbon Subsidization Rate
- 3x
- Astra Subsidization Rate
- 13x
- Hydrogen Subsidization Rate
- 17x
- Opus Subsidization Rate
- 40x
Source: Key facts — Carbon Subsidization Rate, Astra Subsidization Rate, Hydrogen Subsidization Rate, Opus Subsidization Rate
Source: Key facts. Carbon Subsidization Rate: 3x. Astra Subsidization Rate: 13x. Hydrogen Subsidization Rate: 17x. Opus Subsidization Rate: 40x. The chart compares only values that share a unit. Each figure is copied from the story.
Metric chart
- 3xCarbon Subsidization Rate
- 13xAstra Subsidization Rate
- 17xHydrogen Subsidization Rate
- 40xOpus Subsidization Rate
- Carbon Subsidization Rate3x
- Astra Subsidization Rate13x
- Hydrogen Subsidization Rate17x
- Opus Subsidization Rate40x
Extreme Task Latency in Private Benchmarks
During private benchmark evaluations, Gemini 4 Carbon spent close to an hour completing tasks that routinely took competing models Opus and Astra only a few minutes. Practitioners evaluating real-world usage emphasized that Carbon demonstrated unacceptably slow execution speeds.
Subsidization Multipliers and Post-Introductory Rates
The evaluations also accounted for post-introductory pricing and subscription subsidization multipliers across models. Carbon received an effective subsidization rate of only 3x, compared to 13x for Astra, 17x for Hydrogen, and 40x for Opus, making it far less subsidized relative to alternatives.
When to use
- When evaluating frontier model alternatives under post-introductory rate conditions
When NOT to use
- When real-time interactive responsiveness is mandatory
- When relying on heavily subsidized provider quotas
What to do today
- Benchmark execution latency between Gemini 4 Carbon, Opus, and Astra before adopting Carbon in time-sensitive pipelines.
- Factor the 3x subscription subsidization rate and post-introductory pricing into long-term infrastructure cost models.
Step names are taken from What to do today.
Step names are taken from What to do today. Benchmark execution latency between Gemini 4 Carbon, Opus, and Astra before adopting Carbon in time-sensitive pipelines.. Factor the 3x subscription subsidization rate and post-introductory pricing into long-term infrastructure cost models.
- Benchmark execution latency between Gemini 4 Carbon, Opus, and Astra before adopting Carbon in time-sensitive pipelines.
- Factor the 3x subscription subsidization rate and post-introductory pricing into long-term infrastructure cost models.
